Site Meter Copyright Talk » 2007 » February

Archive for February, 2007

Is it legal to steal a title?

Wednesday, February 28th, 2007

Yesterday I alluded to the black fading to gray area of the copyrightability of short phrases like titles and slogans. In general, such things are not protected by copyright, but if the correct alignment of stars occurs, on certain days of years with the proper moon phases, they are protected.

Okay, it’s not really that mysterious, but sometimes short phrases are protected by copyright, and it depends on the particular circumstances of the phrase and the use in question. There is not black and white rule that will tell you in advance whether a particular use is okay.

What it comes down to is a few key factors, most of which are subjective judgment calls. If the phrase is truly unique or inordinately clever, such that it is unlikely someone else would come up with it independently, or if the phrase is closely associated with particular famous characters, then the courts are more likely to find a copyright infringement IF the phrase is being used for commercial gain for the person or company using the phrase.

[Note: it is a common misconception that as long as you are not making money off of using a copyrighted work, then it is okay to use it. That is NOT true; but in the case of short phrases it is mostly true. Don’t you just love the law?]

The clearest example is from a California district court case in 1979, where the writer of a short slogan that was used on a greeting card sued a t-shirt manufacturer that was printing the same slogan on t-shirts for sale. The court said that the phrase, “I may not be totally perfect, but parts of me are excellent,” had met a higher standard of originality, uniqueness, and cleverness, and therefore was the type of work intended to be covered by copyright laws – no matter that it was only one sentence.

Keep in mind that some slogans and very short phrases are protected under trademark laws. Trademark overlaps somewhat with copyright, but is an entirely different legal analysis. Trademark does not protect slogans from all other uses, but it will prohibit a use that causes confusion in the mind of consumers, such as when two competing stores use the same name. Stores that serve completely different markets may be legally be able to use the same name, however.

If it sounds confusing, it’s because it certainly can be. But most confusion can be avoided by doing two things – asking permission, and staying away from things that feel like “stealing.”

Wide Open Spaces

Tuesday, February 27th, 2007

Remember back when you were in school and got your supplies for the year? There was always a brand new package of notebook paper and a spiral notebook with pages and pages of blank white paper (or purple or green paper, if you were in junior high). When I was young, the empty paper inspired me – what great pictures and stories I could write! As I got a little older the blank paper brought a small anxiety, wondering what type of papers I would have to write for my teachers. And once I was grown, a blank page on my computer screen and an assignment from my employer could positively intimidate me.

I am pleased to report to you that the wide open spaces of my new blog excite me. Copyright law is both simple and annoyingly complex, all at the same time. Yet it is everpresent in this information age, and this blog is intended to present information and issues that will help all those who deal in any way with copyrighted materials to understand the concepts surrounding this law. Those who will find this blog useful include both those who create copyrighted works, such as authors, musicians, programmers, artists and filmmakers, as well as those who use copyrighted works, such as those same authors, musicians, programmers, artists and filmmakers at times, but also web designers, teachers, marketers, business owners, neighborhood newsletter editors, and the like.

By the way, the title of this post, Wide Open Spaces, is also the title of a song written by Susan Gibson and recorded by the Dixie Chicks. Dixie Chicks I can use it because titles, slogans and other short phrases generally cannot be copyrighted, according to material put out by the US Copyright Office itself. But that’s not the end of the story. Although courts will give the interpretation of the law by the Office great weight, the courts themselves decide on the interpretation of the law. In the case of short phrases, there have been a number of lawsuits brought for infringement of small, even tiny, strings of words. Sometimes courts have held that very short phrases are covered by copyright.

So there you see the simple move into the complex. Which is why a blog like this can probably cover all the wide open spaces of empty white screen ahead of me. Welcome to the journey.

About Copyright Talk

Copyright touches writers, music lovers, teachers, musicians, businesses, artists, amateur filmmakers, students, libraries, and publishers – to name just a few! In other words, these days everyone is affected by copyright and everyone needs to have at least a basic understanding of it. Copyright Talk discusses issues and developments everyone needs to know about.

Copyright Talk Author(s)
    » Pamela-Parker

Business & Finance Channel Posts

  • The immaturity of corporate america
    Have you ever felt like this? [caption id="attachment_162" align="alignnone" width="300" caption="Stay Away!"][/caption] When I was a kid we used to get these little cards sometimes that had a [...]
  • YouTube, Copyright, and the DMCA
    Yesterday saw a possibly dramatic development in the YouTube world. The DMCA (digital millenium copyright act) includes a provision designed to address the concerns of copyrght holders over the [...]
  • Jackson Browne and John McCain
    Sometimes you get a say, and sometimes you don't. Jackson Browne alleges he should have had a say is whether his recording of his song was used in a political commercial for John McCain, and he's [...]
  • Court Reinforces Control Concept in Copyright
    It seems obvious, but it never hurts to have a court say it's true. Money is not the only thing that makes the world go 'round, and free does not mean anything goes. Briefly, an open-source [...]
  • Scanning Photos
    Photos, of course, are covered by copyright. If you've ever been married, or had professional head shots taken, or you have kids whose after school activity hired a professional photographer to take [...]
  • Email - what happens when you die?
    Every original work of authorship that is fixed in a tangible form is protected by copyright. That includes letters and - these days - email. Which means that when you die, those emails may be part [...]
  • O-Blige Me, Mary
    [caption id="attachment_212" align="alignleft" width="200" caption="Broadcast"][/caption]Work-for-hire rules can trip up more than just the authors. The general rule is that copyrightable work [...]
  • Magic Copyrights
    Just thought I would note that copyright registration is not a magic thing. It does two main things for you: 1. protects your interests in the event of an infringement 2. makes it slightly [...]
  • Motivational Quote of the Day
    "Throughout the centuries there were men who took first steps down new roads armed with nothing but their own vision." - Ayn Rand (1905 – 1982), novelist, philosopher, playwright and [...]
  • Presentation and Communication Skills Workshop in Phoenix
    Founded by Professional Actors and Fortune 500 Executives, Pinnacle Performance trains globally, using it's time-tested Performance-Based Training Method™ to teach business professionals the [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • John Cena " Blue Collar GUY"
    Jim ross has posted an update on hs website..JR's bar-B-Q.com. Jr couldn't believe his eyes that just hours ago, John Cena had surgery and already he was walking around with great spirits. Late [...]
  • Bumbershoot News
    [...]
  • PCs Make a Fashion Statement at PROJECT
    Microsoft to highlight PCs with Windows that are fashionable and downright cool. The New Black Why does Microsoft, primarily a software company, care about the physical design and style of a [...]
  • ‘Chuck’ Gets Full-Season Pick Up
    NBC has given an early back-nine order to Chuck, just over a month before the second-season premiere. Chuck’s first season held its own in the ratings, but was cut short due to the writer’s [...]
  • Auburn Alumni Association pre-game hospitality tent relocated to South Donahue Drive
    AUBURN - The Auburn Alumni Association’s pre-game hospitality tent will be open at a new location for Auburn alumni and football fans. Relocated to the lawn of Auburn’s Wallace Center at 210 [...]
  • How Much is Enough?
    I'm wrestling with my inner self and trying to keep my mouth shut in order to keep peace at work. A coworker and her husband are witnessing the abuse of a dog behind their house. They have called the [...]
  • The Importance of Having a Crap Notebook
    I don’t like fancy journals. Hardbound is great for books, but when it comes to things I write in, spiral bound please. No fancy covers – though hard covers can be nice when you write on the [...]
  • 7 Habits - Conclusion
    [Intro] [Habit One] [Habit Two] [Habit Three] [Habit 4] [Habit 5] [Habit 6] [Habit 7] [Conclusion] And here we are - at the end of our little journey that examined the 7 habits of highly [...]
  • Tracy Chevalier Keeps My Midnight Oil Burning Bright
    When came time to pick out a new book to read after finishing Barbara Kingsolver's Animal Dreams, it was a no-brainer: I had to finally start Tracy Chevalier's newest novel Burning Bright. The [...]
  • Cooking with the Boys.
    Tonight it's Dan and Memphis' turn to cook. The main course? Meatloaf. Instructions verbally gotten from Renny, the boys go to work. And I start giggling... how cute are these two? Seriously? [...]