Site Meter Copyright Talk » Blog Archive » It’s not just bad guys

It’s not just bad guys

by Pamela Parker

A couple of guys made a big splash on YouTube with somne video lessons on how to play guitar that became VERY popular.

Problem was, they had not obtained a license to publicly perform the popular songs they were teaching. Now before you worry about every music lesson going on in the back rooms of music stores and band halls of schools all over the world, this was not the normal music lesson scenario. Instead of a one on one lesson between a teacher and student, these were videos of a musician playing the songs, and the videos were placed on YouTube with the specific intent that they would be viewed by the public - and they were, viewed by hundreds of thousands of people, in fact.

Although the two guys teaching in the videos thought their use of the songs would be welcomed by the songwriters, that is not their call to make. The owners of the song get to decide whether they want the song used, and if they do, the owners of the song get to decide how much they think is a fair price. if the owners believe free is fair and they want to let the song be used for free, then they can decide that. But the other side - in this case the performer - does not have the right to move forward on a plan that THEY think is fair whether or not the other side agrees (and in this case, the other side hadn’t even been asked what they thought). It would be like a couple going to look at a house they were considering buying, and having the seller close the deal and obligate the couple to terms the seller determined were fair but that the couple were never told about until after the fact. it doesn’t matter how objectively “fair” or “beneficial” a use of a song is, the owner still gets to decide whether they want to agree.

In this case, the popular video lessons were saved when the two teacher guys and the owners of the song rights worked out a partnership on terms that all parties actively agreed to.

Here’s the full story.


Leave a Reply


About Copyright Talk

Copyright touches writers, music lovers, teachers, musicians, businesses, artists, amateur filmmakers, students, libraries, and publishers – to name just a few! In other words, these days everyone is affected by copyright and everyone needs to have at least a basic understanding of it. Copyright Talk discusses issues and developments everyone needs to know about.

Copyright Talk Author(s)

Business & Finance Channel Posts

  • Time to buy FAS
    FAS is a Direxion Financial Bull 3X Shares (ETF) The Market to Market rule changes that may come next week can potentially sky rocket financials. I have FAS calls (super leveraged) that I will hold. [...]
  • Copyright Basics in the Digital World
    Copyright. The concept is pretty simple – copyright provides a territorial claim to intellectual property (creative ideas set down in a fixed medium) that allows the creator to profit from the [...]
  • Illegal Downloading Court hearing may be Webcast
    Although the RIAA has recently said that it will stop suing individual who may be illegally sharing music files - in other words, people the RIAA believes may be infringing their copyright but not as [...]
  • There's No Law Against Being Stupid
    Or anti-social, or even just plain mean. We tend to collectively cringe at the thought of great art treasures being destroyed, and yet we allow private ownership of art works and the concurrent [...]
  • Obama's Appointments
    Washington lawyer Thomas Perrelli has been nominated by President-elect Obama for the position of associate attorney general, third in command at the Justice Department. Perrelli has much experience [...]
  • DRM for books?
    A recent column in the New York Times considers whether the ease of finding used copies of books is causing - or at least contributing to - the cratering of the publishing business. Although [...]
  • Lawsuits to End?
    The Wall Street Journal reports that the RIAA is planning to end its controversial anti-piracy strategy of filing copyright infringement lawsuits against any and all small time possible infringers, [...]
  • Google Settlement Draws Ire
    The proposed settlement between Google and various book publishers (which still needs final approval from the Court) is slowly getting more and more clear. There are more than 300 pages in the [...]
  • College Test Files
    There's a difference between access and copying. But the difference is not so intuitively obvious in the case of online archives. It is critical, however, in determining the possibility of [...]
  • Song-Swapping Lawsuits Face [real] Challenge
    The quick recap: * peer to peer file swapping is huge * recording industry believes song swapping interferes with sales * Song swapping really is a copyright infringment in many cases * Recording [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Little things
    There are a lot of things that suck about being a part time dad. Not having him here all the time. Going half days on holidays and birthdays. The big stuff that you think about when seperated parents [...]
  • Out Of Key T-Shirt
    Whacked. Not like, "This shirt is whack." Whacked like Tony Soprano whacked. $17 Buy [...]
  • HTC Hero
    For HTC and Android, third time's a charm. The HTC Hero is the handset giant's third Android phone, but arguably their first lust-worthy effort. Continuing the chin motif of the company's [...]
  • Movie Review - "Public Enemies"
    ** STARS In the action-thriller "Public Enemies", acclaimed filmmaker Michael Mann directs Johnny Depp, Christian Bale and Best Actress Academy Award winner Marion Cotillard in the story of [...]
  • Friday Free for All - Communication
    Hello and welcome to the Friday Free-for-All! Inspired by the Weekend Soiree over at Wifely Steps (and pretty much using her idea, to be honest, but you can go over there and play on her site as [...]
  • Video Taping a Show
    This is not allowed. This is not a legal thing to do. That being said, you need to get video footage of yourself performing. What does that mean? You have to do something illegal. It's a double-edged [...]
  • Marijuana Law Reform!
    Urge Congress To Support Marijuana Law Reform!     I'm writing you today to remind you to contact your members of Congress in support of marijuana law reform. Massachusetts Democrat [...]
  • Russell, the love Muscle
    Ok, so how horrible is it going to be to have to self-proclaimed big ego’s on the show at once.  I don’t think I’ve ever seen a reality show with two ego’s as big as the ones this guy [...]
  • Ten Minutes with Author Brian Sandell
    Hello and welcome to Fiction Scribe Mr. Sandell! Thank you! I am very glad, and excited to stop by and visit your blog today. I think we are going to have lots of fun! List five words that [...]
  • QWSTION Office Bag
    Don’t forget your office essentials, connect to business as-you-go. The two-way access reveals a separate 17-inch laptop compartment with neoprene padding for extra protection. Front section [...]