Site Meter Copyright Talk » Blog Archive » Lord of the Rings versus the Evil Empire?

Lord of the Rings versus the Evil Empire?

by Pamela Parker

Long Tail So you sold or licensed the rights to a copyrighted work. Congratulations! Now comes the part that is hard for most creative folks - keeping track of the project and your payments. Whether you handle it yourself, or whether you hire an administrative service to do it for you, it must be done. This is remarkably important when dealing with copyright licenses and waivers and agreements, because the “tail” on these things can be oh so very long, especially in light of the technological explosion we’ve been undergoing for the last hundred years or so.

A great example of this appears in a recent lawsuit filed by the estate of JRR Tolkien, author of the books collectively known as the “Lord of the Rings.” The estate alleges that the makers of the recent film adaption of the books, which was hugely successful (unlike several previous films of the series), owe several million dollars to the estate. New Line Cinema has been sued a number of times by various parties over payments related to these movies. It’s not clear to me whether the suits are happening because New Line is not paying close attention to the royalties they owe, or because the sheer amount of money (in the billions of dollars) that these movies have generated makes them a target, but the fact remains that accounting for royalties can be complicated, and is always tedious and detail laden.

Actually, Tolkien originally sold the film rights, with royalty payments specified, back in 1969, when he was still alive. I believe the first movie based on the books, was not made until 1978. And of course, the live films with the huge gross were released 2001 - 2003. That’s a lot of years to wait, pen in hand, to begin counting (and accounting) for royalties. Without a system in place to track your rights, you could lose significantly. While the Lord of the Rings is unusual in that it would have been hard for anyone associated with the estate to miss the fact that several major Hollywood films had been made and were doing quite well, it could easily have been that the estate would have trouble finding the original 1969 terms of the sale in order to ensure proper payments.

Every copyright owner who sells rights of any kind needs a good record-keeping system.

If you have trouble organizing, you may have health problems as well, says Jummy. Read here.


Leave a Reply


About Copyright Talk

Copyright touches writers, music lovers, teachers, musicians, businesses, artists, amateur filmmakers, students, libraries, and publishers – to name just a few! In other words, these days everyone is affected by copyright and everyone needs to have at least a basic understanding of it. Copyright Talk discusses issues and developments everyone needs to know about.

Copyright Talk Author(s)
    » Pamela-Parker

Business & Finance Channel Posts

  • How To Save Money On Your Copyright Registrations
    Today is the first day of the US Copyright Office's new online registration system. I think. As of 8:11am this morning, July 1, there's no "portal" evident on their site, despite an announcement [...]
  • Bittersweet Quotes of the Day
    - "I think it’s the duty of the comedian to find out where the line is drawn and cross it deliberately." - "Just when I discovered the meaning of life, they changed it." - "My advice: Just [...]
  • Songwriters Reality Check
    I know that songwriters sometimes get overwhelmed at the thought of trying to get noticed by an adoring public - or even any public at all. Somehow, seeing rows and rows of records in a store and [...]
  • Interview with Jay Scherotter of Scottsdale Insurance Company
    Jay Scherotter is the Director of Learning Resources and Organizational Effectiveness for the Scottsdale Insurance Company, a subsidiary of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company. This property/casualty [...]
  • Motivational Quote of the Day
    "We cannot be what we want to be by remaining what we are." -- Max DePree, author of Leadership is an Art (painting: Landscape with Merchants by Claude [...]
  • Lord of the Rings versus the Evil Empire?
    So you sold or licensed the rights to a copyrighted work. Congratulations! Now comes the part that is hard for most creative folks - keeping track of the project and your payments. Whether you [...]
  • Training Leadership Summit in San Diego
    Next month from May 4th to 7th, the Rancho Bernardo Inn in sunny San Diego will play host to Training magazine's 2008 Training Leadership Summit. This event (which builds on the success of last [...]
  • Follow up on the Student Plagiarism case
    Last year - actually, almost exactly a year ago - I wrote about a lawsuit filed by several students over a school requirement that all papers be submitted to a web-based plagiarism checking site. [...]
  • Motivational Quote of the Day
    "The West has always been the epicenter of possibility. One of the ways we forge against mortality is to head west. It's to do with catching the sun before it slips behind the horizon. We all keep [...]
  • MGI posied to go back up--MGI, the company was founded in 1926
    Euronet Worldwide Inc. has proposed paying $1.65 billion in stock for MoneyGram International Inc., which has hit hard times because of its investments in real estate loans. Thats $20 a share [...]

Hot Off The Press