Site Meter Copyright Talk » Blog Archive » Song-Swapping Lawsuits Face [real] Challenge

Song-Swapping Lawsuits Face [real] Challenge

by

The quick recap:
* peer to peer file swapping is huge
* recording industry believes song swapping interferes with sales
* Song swapping really is a copyright infringment in many cases
* Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) has sought to deter illegal file swapping by suing individuals (college students, mostly) for large damage claims, then settling for smaller amounts, typically $3000-$5000 per person.

Critics of the RIAA strategy say, well, they say many things, but the thing that is relevant to this particular post is that the statute under which the RIAA lawsuits are brought is unconstitutional. The short explanation is that the statute may create a criminal offense with a private enforcement mechanism. In other words, the “damages” that the RIAA seeks in these lawsuits are really a “fine” for copyright infringement, but instead of the usual criminal enforcement procedures - that include all the constitutional protections for the defendant - this statute allows enforcement in an ordinary civil lawsuit. The main problem with that is that the person being sued, who is in the position of “defendant,” is not innocent until probven guilty. In fact, nearly all of the lawsuits have settled for the simple reason that individuals will spend far less by settling for a few thousand dollars than they would spend to hire a lawyer to try and defend against the corporate law department of the RIAA, who would think nothing of spending far more on attorney fees than the amount of money they stand to win. They are in it for the deterrence effect.

Anyway, one of these lawsuits is about to be defended by an attorney with the argument that the underlying statute is unconstitutional. This is not an argument that the file sharing is protected or otherwise “okay.” It is merely an attack on the strategy being used by the RIAA. But to the extent that critics are right and the strategy is heay-handed, over-reaching, and unconstitutional, this is an important case.

You can read more from the AP here.


Leave a Reply


About Copyright Talk

Copyright touches writers, music lovers, teachers, musicians, businesses, artists, amateur filmmakers, students, libraries, and publishers – to name just a few! In other words, these days everyone is affected by copyright and everyone needs to have at least a basic understanding of it. Copyright Talk discusses issues and developments everyone needs to know about.

Copyright Talk Author(s)

Business & Finance Channel Posts

  • Copyright Basics in the Digital World
    Copyright. The concept is pretty simple – copyright provides a territorial claim to intellectual property (creative ideas set down in a fixed medium) that allows the creator to profit from the [...]
  • Illegal Downloading Court hearing may be Webcast
    Although the RIAA has recently said that it will stop suing individual who may be illegally sharing music files - in other words, people the RIAA believes may be infringing their copyright but not as [...]
  • There's No Law Against Being Stupid
    Or anti-social, or even just plain mean. We tend to collectively cringe at the thought of great art treasures being destroyed, and yet we allow private ownership of art works and the concurrent [...]
  • Obama's Appointments
    Washington lawyer Thomas Perrelli has been nominated by President-elect Obama for the position of associate attorney general, third in command at the Justice Department. Perrelli has much experience [...]
  • DRM for books?
    A recent column in the New York Times considers whether the ease of finding used copies of books is causing - or at least contributing to - the cratering of the publishing business. Although [...]
  • Lawsuits to End?
    The Wall Street Journal reports that the RIAA is planning to end its controversial anti-piracy strategy of filing copyright infringement lawsuits against any and all small time possible infringers, [...]
  • Google Settlement Draws Ire
    The proposed settlement between Google and various book publishers (which still needs final approval from the Court) is slowly getting more and more clear. There are more than 300 pages in the [...]
  • College Test Files
    There's a difference between access and copying. But the difference is not so intuitively obvious in the case of online archives. It is critical, however, in determining the possibility of [...]
  • Song-Swapping Lawsuits Face [real] Challenge
    The quick recap: * peer to peer file swapping is huge * recording industry believes song swapping interferes with sales * Song swapping really is a copyright infringment in many cases * Recording [...]
  • Google Agreement
    Remember the big dust-up over Google's plans to digitize all books everywhere in the world and beam them into everyone's head so all information throughout time would be universally [...]

Hot Off The Press